Ian Brady Moors Murder Online Petition
June 13, 2007
After more than forty years in Prison and Mental Hospitals do you believe that Ian Brady should now be released? If you think the answer is yes please leave a short comment to that affect in the comments section.
If you feel that he should stay in prison simply state no in the comments section. Please print your web address or home page. If you don’t have one your city or town will be sufficient.
June 17, 2007 at 9:59 pm
Yes, I think he should be released. I think he should be exported to Scotland and left to be in an old folks home as he has served his time has he not? But due to the hatred he will not be let out as he is a Scot and many who bedded Myra who wore a uniform are fearful of his mouth. It is now 43 years since Keith died and I have not given up, he must find a way to disclose the vital cover of Keiths grave as it is near John as he knows and he knows I am there having flown in from Portugal only yesterday.
June 26, 2007 at 11:15 am
Brady himself refuses to be released from prison, and who are we to argue with that? Let him rot in jail, as he let others rot in their graves.
No sympathy, no mercy, no assistance would I ever give him. What he did was beyond forgiveness.Had he stopped at murdering one child, I would still feel the same way. He murdered a known FIVE young people!! Innocents who had done him no harm!
I wish I believed in Hell, because I would pray for him to go there, but I don’t. He got off lightly- 3 meals a day, medical attention, etc etc. And his victims’ families? A lifetime of Hell.
Let him rot!
June 26, 2007 at 8:15 pm
Most people would agree with you but all he did was kill 5 kids. The Catholic Church and Islam have killed millions and yet it’s members are free to walk the streets in spite of the fact that they would do the same tomorrow if they could get away with it.But like I say , most would agree with you…
June 30, 2007 at 8:42 pm
Seeing as Ian Brady has himself stated that he does not wish to be released, I see little point in arguing otherwise…however I would personally support his release from prision if that were what he wanted. I believe that forty years incarceration is time enough. I feel that if it weren’t for the fact that his victims were children, then he would’ve been released from prison long ago.
July 3, 2007 at 12:48 pm
i think the swine should rot in hell, the only good thing he could do now is to give keith”s mother his remains back so she can bury her son. and get closure for her and her family so they have a grave to visit.that would be the only thing that would make her life complete now. and i think he should do that one last thing, as he took her son away he should give him back to her.
then the the bugger starve himself to death
September 11, 2007 at 10:18 am
No
Strange how the media highlight this case (and both perpetrators) to personify EVIL. There has been worse evil in the world. Here in Ireland a member of a religious order who buggered and sodomised children in Ferryhouse and probably other places was sentenced to 36 years in jail but he was out in two.
Let Brady rot in jail.
November 6, 2007 at 7:47 pm
I have just read Brady’s book and I find him a highly intelligent man, though he committed horrible crimes. Brady himself does not wish to be released from prison, but I do think we should respect his desire to end his own life. Every human being deserves to die in dignity. And he is a human being regardless of what he did.
January 31, 2008 at 6:37 pm
If the sorry motherfucker comes out. He hopefully would be put to death by citizens justice. A perverted child molester (killer) should be made made to face the parents court. A nice sentance DEATH BY STONE.
January 31, 2008 at 10:51 pm
Maffboy…
No doubt if he had been a military man or politician and killed thousands of children you would have no problem with that…..
February 15, 2008 at 3:01 pm
no he shouldn’t be released and he shouldnt be put in prison. Put the death sentence on him. He assaulted so many children, some were even killed. If hes going to take away there lives then we can take away his.
May 28, 2008 at 11:00 pm
I think Brady has served his dues. He’s 70 now and harmless, pathetic even. Of course if I was the mother of one of his victims I’d want to rip his heart out, but luckily I’m not. Looking at it objectively, I think society has had its pound of flesh.
June 9, 2008 at 1:00 am
I believe in life for a life. He should have hanged for what he did. The victims are not living now are they so why should he. If he were to ever be released and I were to see him on the streets I would make sure he hangs himself otherwise I will be the hangman.
June 29, 2008 at 8:14 pm
Ian Brady, who has been in prison for over 30 years for murdering three children, last week lost his fight to stop doctors force feeding him through a nasogastric tube, when a High Court judge ruled that their decision to do so was “lawful, rational, and fair.”
Brady, who is detained in Ashworth special hospital near Liverpool, was probably “playing the system” in undertaking his hunger strike, said Mr Justice Kay at the High Court in Liverpool.
The judge accepted the view of James Collins, consultant forensic psychiatrist at the hospital, that Brady’s refusal to eat was “a florid example of hispsychopathology in action.”Dr Collins described Brady as psychopathic and prone to narcissism, egocentricity, histrionics, obsessionality, need for control, paranoia, litigiousness, lack of remorse, and lack of empathy.
In the past he had referred to receiving a “massive psychological boost” from earlier hunger strikes, which he saw as “a battle of wills.”
Brady started his hunger strike last October after he was moved without warning from one ward in Ashworth to another, by a six man control and restraint team in balaclava helmets and full riot gear. His right arm was fractured in the move.
Under English law, a patient who is competent to take decisions may not be treated—including by artificial feeding—against his or her will. The exception is patients covered by the Mental Health Act 1983, who may be treated against their will even if they are competent—but only if the treatment is for their mental disorder.
The judge held that the force feeding was treatment for Brady’s mental disorder. But even if the act had not applied, he was satisfied that Brady was incompetent, and therefore doctors could lawfully feed him in his best interests.
As a result of his severe personality disorder, said the judge, Brady had eschewed the weighing up of information and the balancing of risks and needs. So doctors were legally empowered to supply medical treatment in his best interests.
Brady, aged 62, who attended the hearing but did not give evidence, was making his first court appearance since 1966, when he was convicted of the murder of three children, two of them with his accomplice, Myra Hindley.
The judge said that he was not satisfied that Brady had at any time expressed a clear wish to die. He made no ruling on a hospital authority’s duty or power to prevent suicide.
The judge refused Brady leave to appeal.
——————————————————————————–
Articles from BMJ : British Medical Journal are provided here courtesy of
BMJ Publishing Group
Write to PMC | PMC Home | PubMed
NCBI | U.S. National Library of Medicine
NIH | Department of Health and Human Services
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Freedom of Information Act
I concurr with these symptoms he has expressed in his verbal and in discourse - that is spoken dialogue for the laymen and entertainers who seek him.
July 29, 2008 at 10:51 pm
I think Mr Brady should Be live out his days where ever he wants to, Wether it be prison or the outside! I for one detest this Man! And Also Myra for what they did. The fact that This Evil creature still shows no remorse for his crimes! Id sooner drag Him up to the moors by the scruff of his Neck and Make him spend A night on them And see how he feels then! I hope all the children’s Laughter haunts Him when He sleeps!The fact he does Not just show the police where the body/or Indeed Bodies Are because for all we know there could be more? He should Just lead them to the remains of keith it is unfair! Its gone on far to long now!let the family and Indeed the poor child rest, I find it truly disgusting nothing is Being done about this, why should he have a life when He clearly shows no remorse the government are too keen to protect child killers And any killers for that matter!I say Release him And I will drag him up to them moors Myself And Make the swine dig with his bare hands If necessary! And I’m sure a lot of people feel the same way! I feel so sorry for keiths mother she lost her child to them fiends who admitted to his Murder and admitted in great detail I might add, And still to this day His remains Lay On the moors! I wish the worst for Ian Brady! The very worst that One can Imagine! He does Not deserve to breath the same Air In which We do.
August 11, 2008 at 10:27 pm
“Someone else had Brady’s record and he read out a transcript of one of the tapes they had found in his home. It was of a little girl whose fingers he was cutting off with garden shears because she wouldn’t go down on him. Everyone went a deathly quiet; my viscera writhed in nausea. The little girl was appealing to Brady’s girlfriend , Myra Hindley and asking her to save her from Brady. The Office went very quiet, the high spirits damepened by the cold, clammy presence of evil”
John McVicar - 1960’s Durham Prison Riot - McVicar by Himself pages 67 & 68.
August 11, 2008 at 10:30 pm
Brady will never be released from his hogh security hospital cell and nor should he. Brady should be force fed and kept alive as long as possible in order to prolong his suffering.
August 12, 2008 at 12:02 pm
yeah Brady should be realised
just because he murders doesnt meen that he could be a good person now does it?
if he wants to go then let him!
August 21, 2008 at 9:28 am
pass house press penny white gay stripes white house pass press gay
August 31, 2008 at 4:06 pm
i dont think he should life should mean life
September 9, 2008 at 6:04 pm
Interesting article here I saw a movie about this .Seems she had no remorse but anyway so much time has gone by for the poor parents no closure will ever happen.But then again what is closure.We have a big news here about a little girl missing for 3 months what ever happened to Caylee all the mother does is lie lie lie.Her story changed more then a dozen times http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=5701503&page=1
October 23, 2008 at 8:51 am
It’s been interesting to read the differing opinions people have. The truths and facts as they stand and have been variously pointed out nevertheless remain. Yes, he is a human being. A human being with rights, though limited, who killed at least 5 other human beings, without regard for their lives and pleas for their lives. He is in jail for these crimes. He may be intelligent,but he is also disturbed. He may be 70, but he got to live to 70,by choice or not. His victims were denied that privilege. The right to live, get married, have families, careers, grow old. One of those victims was not only denied those things, but his body was never even found, and so in death he was denied, unlike the other four, another right. Burial, and a final resting place. His family have not been able to bury him, pay their respects, and find closure of some sort. His mother ( and other family) will die having never been afforded this peace of mind. This final simple wish and RIGHT. This is part of the ongoing very real horror of crime. For it doesn’t simply end with murder, a trial and a jail sentence. Not for Keith Bennett or his family. For them, it doesn’t end until he is either found and buried, and/or Ian Brady dies. Whether he dies in prison or not. Should he be released? No. His victims can’t be released from death can they? He may not be a danger to society, but society would be a danger to him. The man himself has stated no desire to be released. Only to die. His victims were were denied their right to life, and Ian Brady should be refused his wish to die. I say wish, because he has no ‘right’ to be allowed his death. Why does he want to die? Because he has had enough? Finally, unless and until either he does die, and or Keith Bennett is found and laid to rest, perhaps Ian Brady should be put to (public and media) rest. This would be right and proper final justice. The rest is detail. His story is history.